Skip to main content

Compliance That Holds Between Audits

Devensa AI8 min read

Most compliance programs are built to pass a review. Fewer are built to keep working in the months between reviews, when the attention moves elsewhere and the controls are left to run on their own.

This piece covers the three ways programs break, uses the DOJ’s three questions as an operating test, and lists the fixes that keep a program working between audits.

Image placeholder: Hero image, 1200 × 630. Devensa AI branded graphic for “Compliance That Holds Between Audits”.

TD Bank left its anti-money laundering program without updates for known risks from 2014 to 2023, and 92% of transaction volume, about $18.3 trillion, went unmonitored from January 2018 to April 2024.2 The outcome was a 2024 guilty plea, more than $1.8 billion in DOJ penalties, and an independent monitor.1

Compliance keeps breaking because organizations treat compliance as documentation and audit results, while the controls underneath drift out of date. TD Bank kept an anti-money laundering program on the books while 92% of its transaction volume, about $18.3 trillion, went unmonitored from January 2018 to April 2024. The bank pleaded guilty in 2024.1

What a Compliance Program Has to Do

A compliance program is the set of policies, controls, people, testing, and response processes designed to keep an organization inside the laws, regulations, and commitments under which the organization operates. The program must detect problems, and importantly, describe how work should happen.

Two misconceptions keep breaking programs. The first treats a passed audit or a certificate as proof of compliance. An audit samples for a period. Controls change after the auditor leaves. The second treats compliance as a legal department function, when the controls live in finance, IT, sales, and operations, run by people who rarely see the policy.

Three Ways Programs Break

The design stops matching the business

Between 2014 and 2023, according to the Justice Department, TD Bank failed to update its AML program to address known risks. Senior executives prioritized a “flat cost paradigm” and customer convenience over an adequate program.2 The bank excluded all domestic ACH transactions and most check activity from automated monitoring.2

The business grew. The control design stayed still. The gap widened every quarter.

The cost arrived all at once. Beyond the penalties, TD agreed to remediate the AML program and retain an independent monitor as part of the plea.1 Every control the bank skipped building over a decade now gets built under outside supervision, on a regulator’s timeline instead of the bank’s.

The Justice Department’s 2024 resolution with TD Bank included more than $1.8 billion in DOJ penalties, the largest ever imposed under the Bank Secrecy Act. TD became the first U.S. bank to plead guilty to conspiracy to commit money laundering.1

Behavior moves outside the controls

Policies govern approved channels. People use whatever channel is fastest. The SEC’s off-channel communications initiative, aimed at business texts sent on personal devices and unapproved apps, produced charges against more than 100 firms and more than $2 billion in penalties since December 2021.4

Most of those firms had recordkeeping policies. The policies did not reach the phones.

The lesson applies well beyond broker-dealers. Any organization with a records retention rule, a customer data rule, or an approved-vendor rule faces the same drift. Employees adopt a messaging app, a file-sharing tool, or an AI assistant because the tool solves a problem today. The policy describes a world the workforce left months ago, and nobody compares the two.

Resources get set by budget, not by risk

A compliance team sized to last year’s risk profile falls behind this year’s. TD’s flat-cost approach is an extreme case. The pattern shows up in smaller organizations as one person covering five frameworks, with testing deferred until the next audit.

Image placeholder: Supporting chart or diagram for this section. Devensa AI branded.

The DOJ’s Three Questions as an Operating Test

The Justice Department’s Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs asks prosecutors three fundamental questions: Is the program well designed? Is the program adequately resourced and empowered to function effectively? Does the program work in practice?3

The September 2024 update added expectations on new technology, including whether controls exist to monitor AI used in the business or in the compliance program, and whether compliance staff have timely access to relevant data.3

The second question carries the most weight for growing companies. Prosecutors look at whether compliance has enough people, enough seniority, and direct access to the board or audit committee.5 A program run part-time by a controller with no board access answers the question before anyone asks. Resourcing also means tools. A team reconciling five frameworks in spreadsheets spends its hours on formatting evidence, with little time left for testing whether controls work.

Those three questions make a useful internal test, applied before a prosecutor or regulator applies them. In the Devensa vC-Suite model, running the test belongs to the vCCO, the AI-powered virtual officer for compliance architecture and internal controls.

Where TruMaturity™ Fits

Devensa AI scores Compliance as one of six domains on the TruMaturity™ framework. The AI-mediated assessment produces a Compliance Domain Maturity Score on the CMMI scale, from 1 Initial through 2 Developing, 3 Defined, 4 Managed, to 5 Optimized, and an Overall Effectiveness Score across all six domains.

Gaps become owner-assigned roadmap tasks. Reassessment, typically annual, plus event-driven triggers such as regulatory change, shows whether the score held or slipped.

What Keeps a Program Working

Named control owners. Every key control has an operator in the business and an owner who answers for the control’s performance.

Testing between audits. Sample controls quarterly. Annual audits find drift a year late.

Regulatory change intake. A defined path from a new rule or guidance update to a control change, with a deadline.

Root-cause analysis on every issue. Fix the process, not only the instance. Ask whether the same gap exists elsewhere.

Data access for compliance. The compliance team reaches transaction, communication, and system data without a six-week request queue.

Five Fixes to Start With

  1. List your top ten compliance obligations and the control behind each one. Mark any control with no named owner or no test result from the past year.
  2. Test three of those controls this month, outside the audit cycle.
  3. Map where employees communicate with customers and partners. Compare the map with your recordkeeping policy.
  4. Compare compliance headcount and budget against business growth over the past three years.
  5. Apply the DOJ’s three questions to your own program and write down the honest answers.

How Devensa AI handles this

Devensa AI scores Compliance on the TruMaturity™ scale and keeps control evidence current between reviews, so the program shows how it is running on an ordinary day. A virtual Chief Compliance Officer (vCCO) on the platform tracks obligations, owners, and remediation.

Frequently asked questions

Why do compliance programs fail after passing an audit?

Audits test a sample from a past period. Business processes, technology, and regulations keep changing afterward. Without continuous testing and a regulatory change process, controls drift out of alignment between audits, and the next finding arrives as an enforcement action instead.

What does the DOJ look for in a compliance program?

The DOJ’s Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs asks whether the program is well designed, whether the program is adequately resourced and empowered, and whether the program works in practice.3 Prosecutors look for evidence of operation, not only written policy.

Is compliance the legal department’s job?

Legal interprets obligations. The controls run in finance, IT, HR, sales, and operations. Effective programs assign control ownership in the business and give compliance the authority and data access to verify performance.

How often should compliance controls be tested?

Test high-risk controls at least quarterly, starting with the controls tied to the largest penalties or the most customer harm, and after any material change to the process, system, or regulation behind the control. Annual testing alone leaves long windows of undetected drift between reviews.

How does Devensa AI support compliance?

The platform scores Compliance on the TruMaturity™ CMMI-based scale alongside five other domains, converts gaps into owned tasks, and flags reassessment when regulations change. Every AI-generated document or recommendation passes a human approval gate before publication. When did someone last test whether your most important control works, outside an audit?

See It Running on Your Own Program

Devensa AI scores all six governance domains on TruMaturity™ and keeps the evidence behind each score current. Early access is open now.

Join the early access list: devensa.ai/early-access

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of Justice, “TD Bank Pleads Guilty to Bank Secrecy Act and Money Laundering Conspiracy Violations in $1.8B Resolution,” October 10, 2024. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/td-bank-pleads-guilty-bank-secrecy-act-and-money-laundering-conspiracy-violations-18b
  2. U.S. Department of Justice, Criminal Division, United States of America v. TD Bank, N.A., case summary. https://www.justice.gov/criminal/case/united-states-america-v-td-bank-na
  3. Sidley Austin, “Compliance Programs Expected to Evolve With Technology: DOJ Updates Corporate Compliance Guidance to Include Artificial Intelligence,” October 2024, on the DOJ Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs. https://www.sidley.com/en/insights/newsupdates/2024/10/compliance-programs-expected-to-evolve-with-technology
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission off-channel communications initiative, as summarized by Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, January 2025. https://bclplaw.com/en-US/events-insights-news/sec-off-channel-communications-enforcement-sweep-continues-settlements-by-12-firms-and-assessments-of-over-dollar63-million-in-penalties.html
  5. Global Investigations Review, The Guide to Compliance, Fourth Edition, “How the DOJ’s CEC Unit shapes corporate compliance.” https://globalinvestigationsreview.com/guide/the-guide-compliance/fourth-edition/article/how-the-dojs-cec-unit-shapes-corporate-compliance-key-insights-businesses